Great on Paper. But Right for Your Business?
A strong CV, impressive interview and proven track record do not always guarantee the right leadership appointment. For SMEs, understanding the person behind the experience - their motivations, values and how they will complement the existing team - can make all the difference. We explore how psychometric profiling can help businesses make more informed appointments and build stronger leadership teams.
Great on Paper. But Right for Your Business?
A strong CV, impressive interview and proven track record do not always guarantee the right leadership appointment. For SMEs, understanding the person behind the experience - their motivations, values and how they will complement the existing team - can make all the difference. We explore how psychometric profiling can help businesses make more informed appointments and build stronger leadership teams.

You Can Recruit the Best Candidate and Still Make the Wrong Appointment
Why understanding the person behind the CV could transform your next leadership appointment.
An outstanding CV, a compelling interview, excellent references and a proven track record. Surely that is enough to make a confident appointment?
Not necessarily. One of the biggest challenges in senior recruitment is that appointing the best individual does not automatically mean appointing the right person for your business. This is particularly relevant within SMEs, where leadership teams are smaller, relationships are closer and individual personalities can have a significant impact on performance.
A successful appointment is not simply about previous achievements. It is about how someone will contribute to your organisation, work with those around them and complement the strengths already within your leadership team. These are factors that can be difficult to establish through even the most thorough recruitment process.
Looking Beyond the CV

When appointing a senior leader, there are important questions that traditional recruitment methods do not always fully answer. How will this individual respond under pressure? What really motivates them? How will their leadership style complement the existing team? Will they bring different perspectives and strengths, or simply reinforce what is already there?
Psychometric profiling and leadership assessment can add another dimension to the recruitment process, providing valuable insight into individual strengths, motivations, working preferences and potential behaviours under pressure.
The objective is not to replace interviews, references or professional judgement, but to strengthen them. Used effectively, profiling can support better-informed appointment decisions, more revealing interview questions and a stronger transition into the business.
Why Are More SMEs Not Using Profiling?
Psychometric profiling is well established within many larger corporates and private equity-backed organisations, yet its adoption across the SME community is less consistent.
Through our conversations with business leaders, we have identified three recurring barriers.
- The first is familiarity, with many SME leaders having limited experience of profiling or uncertainty about its benefits.
- The second is cost, with a perception that meaningful assessments are expensive and better suited to larger organisations.
- The third is complexity, with such a wide variety of tools available that understanding which assessment is appropriate can feel overwhelming.
Not all profiling tools measure the same characteristics, nor are they designed to answer the same questions. Choosing an unsuitable approach can produce considerable information without necessarily delivering the insight that matters most.
There Is No Single Best Profiling Tool
We have been advocates of leadership assessment for some time, but rather than simply selecting a preferred provider, we wanted to develop a broader understanding of the market and the options available.
We have engaged with assessment providers and, importantly, some of the most experienced users and advocates of psychometric profiling across our professional network. Our objective was to understand which approaches offer the greatest value in different recruitment and leadership situations.
Our research has focused on four established approaches: Insight to Hire, Saville Wave, Hogan and Lumina Spark/Select. Each offers different strengths, from assessing suitability for a particular role and supporting candidate comparisons to exploring leadership motivations, potential risks and team dynamics.
Our conclusion is that there is no single best tool. The most appropriate assessment depends on the situation, the appointment and what the organisation needs to understand.
The value comes from selecting the right assessment and using its findings intelligently alongside the broader recruitment process.
Building Great Teams, Not Just Recruiting Great Individuals

Perhaps the greatest opportunity for SMEs lies beyond the initial appointment decision. Recruitment is often considered complete once the successful candidate accepts the role, when in reality this marks the beginning of another important challenge.
How quickly can the new leader establish effective relationships? How well do they understand the leadership styles of their colleagues? Where might differences in approach create friction, and where could complementary strengths improve decision-making and performance?
The right profiling approach can help organisations explore these questions before and after an appointment, providing a shared understanding of different working styles, identifying potential areas of tension and supporting more effective onboarding.
This does not mean creating leadership teams in which everybody thinks or behaves alike. Quite the opposite. The strongest teams often bring together people with very different but complementary capabilities, perspectives and personalities. The challenge is ensuring those differences become strengths rather than sources of conflict.
Making Profiling More Accessible to SMEs
We believe psychometric profiling deserves a more prominent place in senior recruitment, particularly within growing and ambitious SMEs. Not because every appointment requires an extensive assessment programme, but because the right assessment, used appropriately, can provide valuable additional insight.
The cost can also be relatively modest compared with the overall investment involved in recruiting a senior leader, particularly when considering the potential consequences of an unsuccessful appointment.
Our approach is to help clients navigate the available options, identify the most appropriate assessment and use the findings to support recruitment, onboarding and leadership development. Whether exploring suitability for a particular role, understanding potential leadership risks or assessing how someone could complement an existing board, the starting point remains the same.
What are we trying to understand, and which approach will help us make a better decision?
Better Decisions, Stronger Teams and Lasting Impact
Senior appointments can shape the direction, culture and performance of an organisation for years. We should therefore use every appropriate resource available to make those decisions as well-informed as possible.
Psychometric profiling is not a crystal ball and cannot guarantee success or replace experienced judgement. However, used intelligently, it can bring valuable insight to some of the most important decisions a business makes.
Ultimately, the objective is not simply to recruit an outstanding individual. It is to appoint someone who will make an outstanding contribution to the wider team and organisation.
Want to Understand Which Profiling Approach Is Right for Your Business?
We have brought our research together in a 15-page Management Assessment Guide, drawing on conversations with providers and experienced users across our network.
The guide reviews four established psychometric assessment approaches, examining their relative strengths, practical applications, costs and the situations in which we recommend their use.
Whether you are considering a senior appointment, reviewing your leadership team or simply interested in understanding the potential benefits of profiling, we would be happy to share our findings.
Contact us to request a copy of our Management Assessment Guide or arrange an informal conversation about how profiling could support your next appointment.











